Rudy's Pizza Napoletana - Sheffield in Sheffield

Amazing proper pizza, puts you off Domino's!

Food and cocktails were amazing. Service was pretty slow on noticing when drinks were empty/finished meal but overall it a good experience because the pizza made up for it. Decently priced. Definitely recommend!

Came here for my husband's birthday with our extended families and had a wonderful time. Pizza as always was delicious, with options to suit everyone, with some unique flavours! Atmosphere here is relaxed and easy going which we love.

I liked the options available but took a while to get served and a few items were missing and wrong items bought to table. One staff member seemed to suggest we didn't know what we'd ordered when it turned out that actually it was the waiters first day 😅

I am writing this review as I have received an email asking me to. 1. I am sick of organisations emailing me every time I draw breath asking me to review their services - I selected no emails when I booked which should mean no emails. Usign the guize of a review to get around the marketing email constraints is not acceptable. 2. It took some time form someone to come and take our order. Once taken, the food arrived promptly and was enjoyable. 3. Our booked table was right next to the door. A storm porch has been constructed from canvas (?), however, everytime the main door was opened, the freezing cold outside air came in meaning we were eating in the cold for the duration of our visit. 4. The W.C.'s were not particually clean.

Best pizza I had in a very long time!

Awful pizza. Wet and soggy due to overload of thin and runny tomato sauce (though the colour was right) with visible oil on the surface.

Pizza is good even though it has a soggy centre. The environment is loud and not suitable for people with noise sensitivity, including loud music that makes things worse when the place is already crowded. We're sat at table 15 with the waitress's station behind our back, noticing her watching us eating, very unpleasant feeling. Toilets super dirty and badly kempt, 2 sets of stairs to go to the toilet so not suitable for everyone. I would not return.

Good service. However very noisy, seems they've packed tables in. Made a wrong assumption that there would be a good selection of vegetarian pizzas, unfortunately that's not the case, quite unusual in 2024.

Family Xmas visit Dec 25, and we all enjoyed it here. Friendly, attentive servers always keen to help. Regarding actual food, the pizzas we ordered were all delicious as was the ample combinational starter. All in all, this is well worth a visit in the centre of Sheffield, and we enjoyed the relaxed kind of vibe during a busy time. We will definitely return when possible.

We have visited the Sheffield Rudy's lots of times and it is always tasty, dependable pizza. Freshly made crisp yet soft bases with generous toppings and a very welcoming atmosphere. Definitely one to book ahead to avoid disappointment!

One of the best pizza places in Sheffield, especially if you like Italian style pizza. All pizza options were super tasty and the dough was amazing. Highly recommended.

Excellent salad, pizza, vibes and service

Went into Rudys for a collection on Christmas Eve and received some of the best customer service I’ve had in a long time. Given they were busy the staff were amazingly accommodating and chatty. This was more reason than any to return as an instore customer! Thank you so much, will deffo be recommending!

Always reliable. Good pizza, in a vera Neapolitan style. Good service, nice range of drinks and an extra plus-point for our waiter knowing about Fairport's Cropredy Festival!

It was very busy but the pizzas were excellent and very authentic.

Went with work for our Christmas do, pizza was the best I've had. But expensive, but what do you expect?

Amazing vibe really nice atmosphere. Staff were sublime, really helpful. Food was 15/10 amazing place will definitely recommend and come back

The food tasted phenomenal, portion sizes were insane. Staff were all so nice and attentive. It’s a must go if you’re visiting sheffield

Nice place and good service. We will be returning.

My first time at Rudy's after many recommendations from friends. I went with a friend on 12th Dec without a reservation. The pizzas were delicious and flavoursome. We were served by Luke, who was professional, charming and funny. Definitely a credit to Rudy's. I'll make this place my go to for pizza.

Neapolitan pizza cooked very nicely. The service was excellent - we had a brilliant waiter - and it was all at a very reasonable price.

Love this place! If your looking a bite to eat in sheff this is the place to go! Not only are their pizzas divine and great value, the atmosphere is so warm and relaxed. We had a late lunch and had such a pleasant afternoon at Rudy’s. The lovely woman who seated us and took our order (sorry for not getting your name) is a credit and instantly made us feel so welcome, we had a three month old baby with us and she made sure we had a table we were comfortable with (with having a pram etc) which can sometimes be stressful enough when going out for food with a young baby! One of the chefs seen our little one was a little unsettled and came over and introduced himself and smiled and waved at our little boy and told us he had a four week old at home and had a lovely chat with us, again making you feel so welcome, what lovely friendly staff you have! On top of all of the above, our food was top class and full of flavour, I had the carni pizza, every bite was wonderful! We also had their salads which were super fresh! Next time we are in Sheffield and fancy some food we know where we will be going 😊

If disappointment was a place, it would be this one. There are much better and much cheaper pizza places all over this city.

My second visit and Rudy's did not disappoint! Once again the food and friendly staff were excellent. I went this time with a friend who had not had the Rudy's experience but he is now a convert and says he will return. Thank you to all the staff for another wonderful visit.

Best pizza in Sheffield. My friends couldn't stop recommending Rudy's to me. My partner and I really enjoyed it and we just been to Italy! Friendly staff and great atmosphere with cute fairy lights ✨️

Went here for my birthday. Served by Rebekah, she was lovely along with her other colleagues! Everyone was very friends and we were got everything fast :)

We had lunch here today, and it was absolutely fantastic! The starter was incredible, and the pizza was the best I’ve ever had. Perfectly cooked and full of flavour. I’m so glad we have such a great pizza restaurant here in Sheffield. Highly recommended!

Maybe one of the best pizzas in Yorkshire. Original Neapolitan pizza. Baked for 60 seconds at 450°C. Just delicious. FOH was just amazing. Super friendly and motivated. Thank you, I will be back

Amazing staff and amazing food, very highly recommend for a great evening meal with friends or family!

Great food and reasonable prices

Best place ever❤️ food is lovely and staff amazing 🥰🥰

Creo que debemos ser delincuentes seriales después de haber venido aquí por bastante tiempo. ¿Por qué? El personal es genial, así como la comida. Hamish nos dio una bienvenida muy cálida y recordó el vino que nos gusta así que puntos extra por eso! Nuestra comida fue servida por Jess y Susza, que eran muy amables y acogedores. Tendremos que seguir volviendo por más. Gracias al equipo de Rudy. Nos vemos pronto.

Beautiful mouthwatering pizza for all of us👍🏼

I had lunch here on a Saturday during a recent conference in Sheffield and can highly recommend the restaurant. It was very busy, with only a few seats empty but the kind and attentive staff seated me at the bar, where I could see the pizzas being made freshly. I had the Cinghiale pizza, which comes with wild boar salami and roquito peppers. The pizza was amazing, one of the better ones I’ve ever had and definitely the best I’ve had in the UK. All the ingredients are fresh and the pizza was nicely balanced with a delicious, fluffy and light dough and a nice mix of savory, sweet and spicy toppings. The prices are fair and the staff is friendly and fast. I can also recommend the homemade lemonade as a drink.

Great pizza- shout out to Rebekah for being fantastic as well!

Lovely place. Saturday afternoon was quite busy, but we managed to get a table. The pizza was amazing. Highly recommend 👌

Comida increíble Tuve pizza triple pepperoni que era encantador. Gran servicio brillante vibraciones sin duda volveremos pronto. Gritar a Susan que nos sirvió que era grande

Pizzas were very nice. We all had different ones but all were well received.

First time I've been, excellent quality pizza. The food came incredibly fast. Definitely recommend. Went for lunch on a work day. Super quick service.

Great Neapolitan style pizza with tasty dippers. The starter sharing plate was also very good. The wine was not great, but at least it was cheap. Overall a great evening of food and vibey atmosphere. It gets quite busy so would recommend booking ahead of time. Great location!

Not a big fan of pizza but the pizza here is surprisingly good. And the environment is cozy and quiet, staff veryfriendly. Ps: toilet very clean.

Visited Rudy’s with my family for the first time. I have a 1 year old boy and the staff were super accommodating. My dad was also with us who is in his late 70’s and doesn’t actually usually do pizza but he loved the food. Would 1000% recommend the campana, the cured meat selection was gorgeous also the chili honey dip is a must have. The portion sizes are generous, we ended up taking some pizza home with us! The pizza was a perfect combination of crispy and doughy and I think the pricing is very good for the quality and food portion sizes. We visited in the day time but I’m looking forward to going back for more of a late evening vibe, being located on division street makes perfect placement for date night. Excellent service and excellent food, can’t wait to return!

I've visited a few Rudys branches, I would say Sheffield is my favourite, always great service, great atmosphere, and the best pizzas . This is why I keep coming back , I love the fact that the pizza bases are made on site and not shipped in . 🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕

We ordered from Rudy's, waited an hour for delivery. When it arrives only 3 pizzas came - having spent £90 total. Upon ringing Rudy's we spoke to the manager who gave a verbal apology and said she couldn't do anything as it was third party. Seeing as it is Rudy's responsibility to ensure the food is given to the driver, it is somewhat within their responsibilities. They declined to send the food in taxi and said we had to pick it up. Safe to say we have been disappointed ordering from Rudy's and the lack support from their team.

Excellent pizza, wine, and service. It was very warm in the restaurant so don't wear a big jumper.

Honestly...one of the best pizza restaurants I've ever been too! Welcomed my family and I...and my dog. Water bowl and ham for the dog. Also let us carry on eating and relaxing way after closing time. Fantastic restaurant and staff....

Delicious pizza and great service.

Escuché cosas increíbles que nadie se detiene en este lugar, así que tuve que probarlo en mi camino al Ayuntamiento para un evento! Shaky comenzó con el primer servidor, que claramente se estaba obligando a ser amable y salió bastante brutal y corto, para ser honesto. El segundo servidor era encantador, sin embargo, y ella no podía hacer lo suficiente para ayudar. La comida y las bebidas eran increíbles. Impresionante pizza auténtica que sabía como la propia Italia. Precioso Tiramasu que se podía decir que estaba recién preparado. Increíble restaurante que recomendaría a cualquier amante de la pizza por ahí!

Had a lovely evening for my friends 21st. Daisy was an absolute gem and treated us amazing! Had a fab time!

I love eating at Rudy’s as it is always excellent! I came in yesterday and was served by the new lady with brown hair; she was amazing and made sure everything was perfect.

Mi primera visita a Rudy y sin duda no será la última. Personal servicial, amable y atento, excelente comida y una buena selección en el menú tanto para comida como para bebida. Servicio muy rápido y precios razonables. Definitivamente voy a hacer más visitas.

Food service & value for money all superb !

Will definitely be going again, we went to get some pre gig food and it was utterly delicious and the service was great.

Popular place with lovely fresh pizza. Extremely attentive staff. Also good variety of drinks on offer

Hands down one of the best pizzas I've ever eaten! It was absolutely delicious. I genuinely considered ordering another one. The service was friendly, efficient and welcoming. Honestly, this pizza was phenomenal. I can't wait to come back. Big up the Kitchen!!!! My server Rebekah was super friendly and professional. Solid service from this one! Next time I'm in Sheffield, THIS is my first port of call! Thank You to the team on this shift for making my dinner break such a pleasant experience.

Great tasting pizzas fast service well worth a visit

We had Margherita, Portobello, Romagnola, and Capricciosa pizzas for our main course, and Tiramisu for dessert! Since I don't eat meat, I tried the Margherita and Portobello, which were both delicious. I had Ruby's homemade lemonade with my pizza, and it went really well with the food. My friends enjoyed the other pizzas we ordered. With the rain outside, the food and atmosphere felt perfect. The staff were super friendly too.

Love the food & service here! We were served by the waitress from Hungary, she made our outing extra special!

Excellent service. Huge pizza 🍕 😋 😍. Delicious

Rudy's pizza is great. This is my favoritepizza place when in Sheffield. Ingredienti are excellent. Service fast and staff very helpful and welcoming.

An absolutely amazing experience. From the superb staff to the excellent food. Nothing to be faulted. The staff are so attentive ensuring that you understand all the specials and the dusky menu.

Suggested by the positive reviews and pleasant experience in Manchester, I visited Rudy's twice during my city break in Sheffield. The first time we were lucky enough to walk in without a booking and get a table for two. Pizza very tasty, fresh ingredients, cool flavour combinations. After this nice experience, we decided to go for pizza the next day as well, but we had already booked a table (even during the week this place is very busy). When we arrived, unfortunately we had to wait another 10-15 minutes because there was no table for us. As an apology we were given lemonade and crips on the house and an equally tasty pizza. I would recommend to anyone who likes Neapolitan pizza at a reasonable price.

Awful service online we ordered a pizza took 2 hours for delivery we try to contact them, no answer, after that time, they said it was delivered and it wasn’t their problem, really disappointed, they didn’t try to sort it out

Daisy and the other staff members were really attentive and helpful :) The portions were really good and we were offered takeaway boxes for any of our leftovers.

First sent us pizzas with no cheese, then sent replacements with loads of cheese and next to no sauce?? Ordered dozens of pizzas from Rudy’s over the years, multiple branches. Never had a single issue, then get 2 bad orders in a row, same night… On top of that the woman was passive-aggressive and rude to me the second time I called to raise it with them?? Strange. Picture of my sauceless pizza (which she was adamant did have sauce). Like they literally only sell one thing - pizza. You’d think they’d be able to get it right! Edit - funny that you comment telling me to email to make it seem like you care, but then ignore the email 🤷‍♂️

Delicious Italian pizza. Very good restaurant. Home atmosphere. Very friendly and helpful staff. Highly recommended to visit this restaurant.

Came here for food the other night and was not disappointed. There pizzas were amazing with lots of variety in choice and very generous sizes.

Not bad. They need to work on the design and service.

I heard the pizza was good and it was better than good. Well worth a visit.

Went the other day and was served by, Hamish He was absolutely lovely and took the time to speak to us in a genuine manor and made our Rudys experience fantastic! It was really refreshing to experience, old-school customer service when the waiter takes time for you, and is not rushing around. Would highly recommend going here as every time we’ve been its amazing! From Amelia & Lawrence

Best pizza place in Sheffield. The triple pepperoni with honey and chilli flakes is so nice. The pale ale is a really nice pint

Excellent pizza, everyone in Sheffield seems to agree meaning best to make a reservation!

Very very nice pizza. Great price. Lovely staff. I turned up without a reservation Friday evening and they found me a spot at the bar. Can't fault it. Will definitely return.

Rudy’s is a great choice of Italian pizza.i got the triple pepperoni, it has this chili honey which compliments the meats and soft cheese. It is perfection. My dad got the nerano. He said it’s one of the best pizzas he’s ever had. You won’t regret coming here. I only have a minuscule problem with this place which is the environment is quite loud and I have a soft voice so it’s difficult to be heard. But the atmosphere is lively and very busy so you know it’s great.

Great place with authentic Napoli pizza. We really enjoyed our food and drinks. They cook a pizza in a wooden stove that makes it crispy outside but chewy texture inside. I really appreciate great service and generous portions, everything was fresh and delicious. The pepperoni with honey and garlic dip is my new favourite. Highly recommend to try if you like a great pizza at a reasonable price.

Tasty good quality food. Never disappoints!

Staff are lovely, nice atmosphere and delicious pizza

Quality pizza!! Managed to eat 3 of them, wouldn't definitely visit again but worried my clothes wouldn't fit. Great service as well.

Same Rudy’s Quality! My first experience of Rudy’s was back at their first Liverpool branch and it was fantastic so when I decided to go for some pizza in Sheffield I thought of Rudy’s - Rudy’s Sheffield has been around for a few years already and I finally managed to try it since its opening on this occasion. Firstly, I was greeted by a warm welcome from the waitress and was seated at a table promptly. I visited on a late Saturday afternoon and it wasn’t busy. There are plenty of tables available for different sizes of groups and the waitress was really nice and polite! After me and friend were seated we ordered our food which arrived quickly too. I ordered the Doppia Mozzarella which costs £11.90, which is very reasonable in my opinion. The pizza is a good size for one person and it tasted great, the crust of the pizza was perfectly stone baked, the usual quality you would expect from Rudy’s Pizza! Overall, I had a nice experience at Rudy’s. The food, service and atmosphere were great. I would definitely recommend to those who want to try authentic Italian pizza. I love Rudy’s Pizza!

If you do great pizza that's all you need to do & these guys do it fantastically & the service was excellent.

Highly recommend, Will definitely be back again soonservice Friendly staff Marvellous pizza .🍕

Great atmosphere, super attending staff members, great selection of drinks, authentic stone oven-baked pizza, overall Fab experience

Great pizza and efficient/ friendly staff. I had the portobello as a white pizza, which was great, as was the three dips we tried.

Sometimes I get awkward when eating in restaurants alone but I never felt that at all as the waitresses were so sweet to me and welcoming. They were helpful about the dishes with my allergies and made sure that I had everything I needed :)

great pizzas and the best staff! Work next door and always enjoy getting pizza from here :)

Luke was our server and they were lovely and very attentive. All other staff we interacted with were equally courteous and warm. The food is incredible with good mix of toppings and choice, and very good value. The decor and atmosphere is great and will definitely come back/recommend.

Great service, good selection of drinks and great pizzas.

Amazing pizza and we were seated quickly.

We had a delicious Cinghiale pizza and rocket and Parmesan side salad. The service was very friendly and helpful and the decor was brilliant, there were even cushions to keep us comfortable!

The best staff ever!! The food is always impeccable and is now our go to for a Sheffield City dinner. Hamish and Harvey are so friendly and super attentive. We ended up chatting to them throughout our meal

Very nice staff, and the pizza is perfect

Best thin crust handmade pizza with affordable rate

Really good pizza served with a smile in record time. Great atmosphere.

Best Pizza in Sheffield , great staff

We booked a table for 9 people on a Monday evening. The pizza was great, however, less than one hour 15 mins, we were told that we had 15 mis left to leave as they had the table was booked, for another large booking. If we had been told this at the time of booking we would have chosen another venue. Really disappointed. S it was our anniversary and we wanted to spend a bit more time with our family. Won't be returning anytime soon. As my granddaughter was hoping for desert. Poor customer service.

Lovely place..made a special memory

Great pizza and good value. Recommend booking as it was busy!

Very good pizza. Lovely staff and nice atmosphere 👌

I have been here twice so far, both times with friends/family. The pizza tastes amazing and is really fresh. Lots of choices for food and drinks here. One of my friends keeps wanting to meet up just to come here again :D It's a 15 second walk from Creams Café too. You can stop there for an amazing dessert afterwards.